April 05, 2024 5 min read 0 Comments

When it comes to wardrobe staples for the athletic man, a well-fitted polo shirt is non-negotiable. Here at Tailored Athlete, we understand that a polo shirt isn't just a piece of clothing; it's a statement about who you are and how you respect your physique.

Whether you're hitting the golf course, attending a casual business meeting, or simply enjoying a day out, the right polo can elevate your style while showcasing your muscular build in the most flattering way.

Read on to discover how the best fitting polo shirts should look and feel, plus the top picks from our curated collection.

What this article covers:

What Makes a Good Polo Shirt?

What distinguishes an exceptional polo shirt from the average is a combination of factors that cater specifically to the needs of athletic individuals.


From our experience, the fabric plays a crucial role; it must be breathable and flexible to accommodate movement and provide comfort throughout the day. Our polos are made from premium stretch fabrics that not only allow for a full range of motion but also maintain their shape and structure over time.


Athletic men lead active lifestyles, so a polo shirt needs to withstand regular wear and frequent washing without losing its colour or form. Through a process of rigorous testing, we prioritize high-quality construction and materials that ensure our polo shirts remain a staple in your wardrobe for years to come.


A good polo shirt should be suitable for various occasions, from casual outings to more formal events. Our polos are designed with this in mind, offering a range of colours and styles that can be dressed up or down, ensuring you look polished and put-together wherever you go.

best fitting polo shirts men


A good polo shirt should offer a 'True Muscle Fit', meaning it should be snug in the right areas – like the chest and arms – to highlight an athletic build without being restrictive. This requires a meticulous design process that considers the unique proportions of an athletic physique, ensuring the shirt complements broad shoulders and a narrow waist.

To sum it up, the makings of a good polo shirt for the athletic man boil down to a harmony of fabric, fit, durability, and versatility – all designed to meet the specific needs and lifestyle of those with a muscular build.

How Should a Polo Shirt Fit an Athletic Man?

For an athletic man, the fit of a polo shirt is paramount, as it needs to complement a muscular physique while ensuring comfort and mobility. A well-fitted polo shirt should adhere to several key principles to enhance an athletic build without compromising on functionality.

Chest and Shoulders

The polo shirt should fit comfortably around the chest and shoulders, allowing enough room for movement without excess fabric. It should accentuate the upper body's muscular form, showcasing the chest and shoulder muscles without pulling or straining across these areas. The seams of the sleeves should align with the end of the shoulders, creating a structured and balanced silhouette.


The sleeves of the polo should enhance the biceps, fitting snugly but not too tightly. After putting it to the test, we've found that the ideal length typically ends around the mid-bicep, highlighting the arm's shape without constricting movement or circulation. This fit ensures the arms are defined, contributing to the overall athletic appearance.

best fitting mens polo shirts


The torso section should taper slightly to follow the natural lines of an athletic body, with a slight allowance for ease and comfort. This 'True Muscle Fit' ensures the polo is not boxy or loose, which can obscure the body's shape, nor too tight, which can be restrictive and uncomfortable. The fit should flatter the physique by emphasising the V-shape of the upper body, narrowing down to the waist.


The length of the polo shirt is crucial for versatility and function. It should be long enough to tuck in for formal occasions but also look good untucked for a more casual look. We've found that a good rule of thumb is for the hem to end around the middle of the trouser fly, providing coverage without excess fabric that could bunch up or look untidy.

Overall Comfort And Mobility

Despite the fitted nature of the polo, it's essential that there is still enough give in the fabric to allow for a full range of motion, particularly across the back and shoulders. Athletic individuals often have broader back measurements, so the polo should accommodate this without restriction.

In summary, a polo shirt fitting an athletic man should highlight the physique's best attributes – broad shoulders, muscular chest and arms, and a tapered waist – while remaining comfortable and versatile for various occasions. The right polo shirt becomes an extension of the wearer, blending style with function seamlessly.

The Best Fitting Polo Shirts: Our Top Picks

Standard Polos

When it comes to classic style, our Standard Polos are unmatched. Each one is crafted with attention to detail, ensuring a perfect fit for those with a muscular build:

best fit polo shirts

Buttonless Polos

For a more relaxed look without compromising on fit, our Buttonless Polos are the way to go:

Open Collar Polos

Our Open Collar Polos offer a unique twist on the traditional polo, ideal for those looking to stand out:

What to Wear with Your Fitted Polo Shirt

To complete your look, pairing your polo with the best fitting jeans or the best fit jeans for big thighs ensures a balanced and stylish silhouette.

For more formal occasions, combine your polo with one of our best fitting suits to elevate your ensemble and add a level of sophistication suitable for any event.

And for those casual days when you still want to look put-together, pair your polo shirt with some tailored shorts for a comfortable yet fashionable option.


Finding the best fitting polo shirts isn't just about picking the right size; it's about understanding how a garment complements your athletic physique, enhances your comfort, and elevates your style.

At Tailored Athlete, we're committed to designing pieces that meet these needs, ensuring that you look and feel your best, no matter the occasion. Our collection is a testament to our dedication to quality, fit, and the athletic lifestyle. So, when you choose a polo from our range, you're not just choosing a shirt; you're choosing a piece that's been crafted with your unique physique in mind.

Explore our collection today and experience the difference of a true muscle fit.

If you want to learn more, why not check out these articles below:



Your location is set to USA

  • Shop in USD $
  • Get shipping option for the US
Go to US site →